REAL THREATS
Container Security & Resource Management
• No resource limits (0, 8): Containers have no CPU/memory limits, enabling DoS via resource exhaustion.
• Root containers without security context (1, 2, 6): All containers run as root with no securityContext (runAsNonRoot, capabilities drop, readOnlyRootFilesystem). This grants full host-level privileges if container breakout occurs.
• HostPath volumes without protection (5, 10, 28, 30): Sensitive host directories (/dev/log, /con/*, /etc/*.pem) are mounted directly, bypassing container isolation. An attacker with container root access can read/write host files.
Credential & Data Exposure
• Private keys/certificates mounted from host (3, 11): TLS private keys and certificates are mounted from host paths without encryption or access controls. If host files are compromised, all TLS-protected communications are at risk.
• SASL PLAIN enabled (4): Cyrus IMAP includes cyrus-sasl-plain, allowing credentials to be transmitted in cleartext if TLS is not enforced.
• LDAP configuration lacks encryption enforcement (25, 26): slapd.conf is mounted from host without validation, and LDAP binds to both encrypted/unencrypted protocols, potentially allowing cleartext authentication.
• Supply chain issues (15-20): Cyrus IMAP source is downloaded via curl without integrity verification (checksums, GPG), timeout, or authentication. This enables MITM attacks injecting malicious code.
Network & Service Configuration
• Multiple ports exposed to host network (7): IMAP, SMTP, and management ports (143, 465, 587, 993, 2525, 4190) are directly exposed on host ports, increasing attack surface.
• No rate limiting on SMTP authentication (12): Postfix lacks rate limiting, enabling brute-force attacks on SMTP AUTH.
• Postfix runs without explicit security context (33): Although it runs as 'postfix' user, no securityContext is defined to further restrict capabilities.
• Postfix TLS configuration not enforced (34): TLS settings are not explicitly configured in container, potentially allowing weak ciphers or protocols.
Authentication & Authorization
• User/group creation lacks least privilege (22): Cyrus user is added to group 'tls' (GID 478) which may grant unnecessary permissions.
• Cyrus IMAP runs as root-equivalent user (23): The 'cyrus' user (UID 76) may have excessive privileges within the container.
ATTACK CHAINS
1. Container breakout to host compromise: An attacker exploits a vulnerability in Cyrus IMAP or Postfix (running as root). With no security context, they gain full container root access. Through HostPath mounts (/dev/log, /con/*), they can write to host system logs or configuration, potentially escalating to host root.
2. Credential interception and service takeover: Due to SASL PLAIN being enabled and potential lack of TLS enforcement (LDAP, SMTP), an attacker on the network can intercept credentials. These credentials can be used to authenticate to LDAP (if cleartext binds allowed) and access email accounts or modify directory data.
3. Supply chain compromise leading to backdoor: The unverified download of Cyrus IMAP source (no checksum/GPG) allows an attacker to MITM the connection and inject malicious code. When built and deployed, this creates a persistent backdoor in the email server.
VERDICT
This deployment has
critical security deficiencies that must be addressed before production use. The most urgent fixes are:
1. Immediate: Add securityContext to all containers (runAsNonRoot, drop capabilities), implement resource limits, and remove HostPath mounts in favor of ConfigMaps/Secrets.
2. High priority: Enforce TLS-only communication, disable SASL PLAIN, implement rate limiting, and fix supply chain issues with verified downloads.
3. Medium priority: Implement least-privilege user configurations and audit logging.
The current configuration is suitable only for isolated testing environments with no sensitive data.